EDITOR’S NOTE: This is a lightly updated Thanksgiving column from 2015. It still rings eerily true. Have a good holiday season.
Commentary by Andy Brack | Recall Thanksgiving afternoon as you watched football and digested turkey after giving much thanks for your freedom, blessings and family.
Imagine hearing the doorbell as you’re dozing. At the door is a young brown woman, heavy with child. She’s wearing a scarf on her head. On the street, you see a beat-up car with a man inside.
The woman holds her belly. “Sir, my husband, Jose, and I have no place to stay tonight. We’re new to this country and haven’t been able to find steady work. We’re cold. We’re hungry. But we’re not any trouble. We’re legal — we’re refugees. Can you help us tonight?”
You’re perplexed, torn, conflicted. What should you do? Like most Americans, you’re generous. You’re kind. But this? Somebody else should deal with it, right? What do you know about these people, this woman who claims her name is Maria?
America, a nation made strong by immigrants, is once again confronting nasty, Joe McCarthy-like debates about immigration — about who should be in the country and who shouldn’t.
Most Americans seem to forget that in just about everyone’s background is an immigrant like Jose or Maria who turned up on these shores to start a better or different life, some as immigrants, some as slaves, and others as refugees from war and violence. With each wave of new arrivals, some Americans were frightened at first, worried by the backgrounds, baggage and competition that the newcomers brought. But over time, each new wave became part of the fabric of the nation, adding new strength to the diversity of people called Americans.
With just about every family’s immigrant past, it’s unsettling how quickly so many forget and fall into xenophobia, the fear or irrational dislike of foreigners. Case in point: [Former] Gov. Nikki Haley, a brown woman and daughter of Sikh immigrants who [in 2015] joined 29 other governors — all but one Republican — in saying Syrian refugees shouldn’t be resettled in the Palmetto State.
Really? The overwhelming majority of refugees, all of whom go through extensive background checks, are women and children. Where’s your Christian charity? Where’s your leadership? You could be a spokesman to highlight how America is the land of opportunity for all. Instead, you conveniently join the crowd of pandering politicians and seem to forget how your family was welcomed into the United States.
Meanwhile, GOP presidential candidates turn up the heat with vitriol and rhetoric, inflaming feelings of fear. Chief fearmonger is billionaire Donald Trump, who talks about maintaining databases of Muslims and making them wear identification, the same kind of labeling done in Nazi Germany to Jews, gays and Communists.
Ladies and gentlemen, this isn’t the America in which I grew up. We’re better than the political nonsense that is fueling the airwaves and social media. The Greatest Generation toiled and fought to preserve freedom for all, understanding what one president said: “The only thing to fear is fear itself.”
[Former] Washington Gov. Jay Inslee wrote that his state would continue to welcome refugees because it’s part of what being American is:
“The American character is being tested. Will we hew to our long tradition of being a beacon of hope for those chased from their homelands? I have always believed that the United States is a place of refuge for those escaping persecution, starvation or other horrors that thankfully most in America will never experience.”
Since 2002 [to 2015], South Carolina accepted 1,813 refugees from 30 countries, according to federal sources. More than a third (680) were from Burma. Iraq was the mother country to 249 and Ukraine to 205. One refugee was from Syria.
Fear, as Inslee notes, is a powerful thing. If we succumb to it, aren’t we letting the terrorists win? Aren’t we letting them change our lives of freedom? We shouldn’t blame people running from terrorists into the refuge of America or France or Sweden for what the terrorists are doing. Instead, we, like other free countries, should welcome them so they can blossom from victims into capitalists.
Andy Brack is editor and publisher of Statehouse Report and the Charleston City Paper. Have a comment? Send to: feedback@charlestoncitypaper.com.
We Can Do Better, South Carolina!
Amen, brother.
Andy, I couldn’t agree with you more with one exception, Nikki Haley, and others came into the country through a legal process. The problem is with those who sneak into the country illegally, some of whom are terrorist and criminals coming here to do harm or to escaping punishment imposed by their homeland for criminal acts. We should welcome immigrants, but they should respect our laws and enter the country legally as millions have.
Haley was born Nimarata Nikki Randhawa at Bamberg County Memorial Hospital in Bamberg, South Carolina, to immigrant Sikh parents from Amritsar, Punjab, India. She was born in AMERICA.
Short comment: My Mother’s parents were immigrants from the former Czechoslovakia. Her father in 1983.
I think I remember that correctly and her Mother arrived in 1904. They both became American Citizens. They had followed the proper rules and arrived quite welcomed by others of their family. No one jumped a border or sneaked in with a fake name.
My Dad’s folks arrived in the late 1750’s. I have never heard of any problems arriving back in that time.